Loading…
We use essential cookies (authentication, your saved goals/stack) by default. With your permission we'll also enable privacy-respecting analytics (Vercel Web Analytics, anonymous load-time metrics) and error-replay diagnostics (Sentry — DOM snapshots only when an error fires) so we can fix bugs faster. Learn more
Head-to-head evidence comparison — which supplement is right for you?
Echinacea wins 1 of 3 categories. Both are solid choices — the best pick depends on your specific goals.
Verdict
Probably helps
6 of 11 studies with measurable effects showed benefit.
Top outcomes
Verdict
Probably helps
9 of 13 studies with measurable effects showed benefit.
Top outcomes
300-500mg extract 3x daily at first symptoms, OR 2.5ml tincture 3x daily
At first sign of symptoms, Multiple times daily during illness
Standardized extract (4% echinacosides or standardized alkylamides)
200-400mg silymarin (standardized extract)
With meals, Split into 2-3 doses
Standardized extract (70-80% silymarin)
With continuous use
When taken at onset
4-8 weeks
8-12 weeks
4 weeks
Identifying immunostimulatory herbal supplements that may flare autoimmune skin diseases: a systematic scoping review
Lupus science & medicine (2025) · Systematic review · n=469
We identified 227 herbal supplements with immunostimulatory properties, of which 15 were most strongly supported by the evidence.
Echinacea Supplementation Does Not Impact Aerobic Capacity and Erythropoiesis in Athletes: A Meta-Analysis
Nutrients (2024) · Meta analysis · n=107
There was also no statistically significant change in erythropoietin (effect size -0.29, p = 0.05, 95% CI -0.75-0.17, I2 = 67%) or maximal oxygen uptake (effect size -0.20, p = 0.95, 95% CI -0.60-0.21, I2 = 0%).
Select Dietary Supplement Ingredients for Preserving and Protecting the Immune System in Healthy Individuals: A Systematic Review
Nutrients (2022) · Systematic review
Immune health products represent approximately 10% of all US dietary supplement sales.
Clinical Efficacy of Curcumin, Resveratrol, Silymarin, and Berberine on Cardio-Metabolic Risk Factors Among Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Systemic Review and Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis
Phytotherapy research : PTR (2025) · Meta analysis · n=1337
For HbA1c, silymarin was more effective than resveratrol (MD -2.08, 95%Cl -3.50 to -0.72) (P < 0.05).
Effects of different natural products in patients with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease-A network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
Phytotherapy research : PTR (2024) · Meta analysis · n=2509
The results of the network meta-analysis showed that artichoke leaf extract confers a relative advantage in reducing the aspartate aminotransferase (AST) levels (SUCRA: 99.1%), alanine aminotransferase (ALT) levels (SUCRA: 88.2%) and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) levels (SUCRA: 88.9%).
Are alterations needed in Silybum marianum (Silymarin) administration practices? A novel outlook and meta-analysis on randomized trials targeting liver injury
BMC complementary medicine and therapies (2025) · Meta analysis · n=3545
According to the findings of this meta-analysis silymarin administration showed a significant reduction in AST (SMD [95% CI]: - 0.670 [- 0.931, - 0.408], p-value = 0.000), and ALT (SMD [95% CI]: - 0.912 [- 1.177, - 0.646], p-value = 0.000) levels.
Based on meta-analyses showing modest SMD of -0.19. Significant heterogeneity between products tested. Evidence stronger for E. purpurea aerial parts preparations.
Based on multiple meta-analyses showing significant ALT/AST reduction. Effect size modest (SMD -0.67 to -0.9). Effectiveness assumes standardized 80% silymarin extract. Lower bioavailability forms may require higher doses.
AI-estimated from published studies. Interpret as directional guidance.
Echinacea has a higher evidence score (9/10 vs 9/10) and wins in 1 of 3 categories.
For reduce inflammation, Milk Thistle has a higher relevance score (95 vs 52).
No known interactions between Echinacea and Milk Thistle have been documented in our database. However, always consult a healthcare provider before combining supplements.